How 'The Fargo Effect' Casts Unexpected Actors as Villains

When Jon Hamm traded in Don Draper's sharp suits for a 10-gallon hat to play a wife-beating cowboy in the fifth season of “Fargo,” he became the latest actor to enjoy a tough turn thanks to the show's casting practices that destroy perception.

“Fargo” executive producer Warren Littlefield explains writer-director Noah Hawley’s unformulated formula that keeps fans on their toes. “'Fargo' walks in the shoes of comedy and also tragedy,” says Littlefield. “When they collide, that's when you have a great 'Fargo.'”

Beginning with its first season in 2014, “Fargo,” based on the Coen brothers’ 1996 film, allowed actors known for their comedic chops to get serious. Nick Offerman came from “Parks and Recreation” to play him straight in “Fargo,” as did Ted Danson of “Cheers” fame, Brad Garrett of “Everybody Loves Raymond” and Dave Foley (“News Radio,” “Kids in the Hall”). ”), who introduced himself this year as a suave lawyer who never gets around to explaining why he wears an eye patch before being shot to death.

Littlefield credits casting director Rachel Tenner with a key role in putting together the show's extravagant sets. “Probably the only suggestion the Coen brothers gave to Noah and me was for Rachel to do local casting when they did 'Fargo' and 'She Really Got Us.' “We love Rachel’s sensitivity.”

Here's a look at the stories behind five actors who have benefited from the “Fargo Effect,” thanks to their stereotype-defying performances.